The Dilemma of the Carriage Horses

By Anthony DiBernardo
PVPHS Class of ‘03


The simple beauty of a carriage horse is timeless. The sense of romance and simplicity draws many to favor the occasional ride. But underneath the nostalgic exterior lurks a horrible and brutal life, one fraught with inhumane conditions that the horses are forced to endure their entire lives. One might think that the beloved horses of New York City are given proper care, as they have been a substantial symbol of the city since the beginning of its forging.

The beautiful beasts of burden of New York look forward to nine-hour workdays, seven days a week without a designated rest period. They may face temperatures ranging from 92 degrees to below 18 degrees Fahrenheit. At the end of their grueling day they are marched back to one of several multi-story stables built more than 100 years ago. Built almost exclusively out of wood and filled with hay, the stables can be turned into a death trap with a simple spark. The stalls, merely 4 feet wide, do not allow the animals to lie down or roll as any natural animal would under normal conditions. The stables are not equipped with a turnout area to allow the horse to buck, kick, roll or run, as this is what the animal requires to remain healthy. The lack of veterinary attention is surprising. One would think that these companies, considering that the true income comes from these horses, would stress better health. Rather, the average horse only receives attention when a problem is evident.

These magnificent creatures deserve the best of care, as they provide joy and transportation to millions a year. Please write to New York City decision-makers as new legislative changes are being made throughout the state. The fate of these creatures could be in your hands.

Click here to read more about legislative victories for NYC carriage horses.

Click here to go back to Legislative Updates and Alerts Articles